Coronavirus Read our latest advice

We use cookies to allow us and selected partners to improve your experience and our advertising. By continuing to browse you consent to our use of cookies. You can understand more and change your cookies preferences here.

Get advice on job dismissal
0117 456 6132
Monday - Friday 8.30am - 6pm
Excluding Bank Holidays


*only £9/month plus a £29 joining fee. You can cancel anytime.

Dismissal - Case studies

It can be necessary for a business to performance manage its employees. However, it doesn’t necessarily mean they can simply jump in and dismiss someone without first giving them a reasonable opportunity to improve. 

A Which? Legal member contacted us after she had been dismissed a week after her employer had raised concerns about her performance.  Having been with the company for almost ten years and without any previous issues with her performance the decision came as a complete shock – most feedback up until then had been very positive. 

Which? Legal Advice 

Our specialist employment law solicitor advised the member that she was likely to have a claim for unfair dismissal and following a period of negotiation, she was offered an acceptable amount of compensation to settle her claims. Using the Which? Legal Settlement Agreement Service, we were able help her reach an amicable resolution, without the need to issue a claim.  

Whilst the member had over two years of service, and therefore ordinary unfair dismissal rights, it can be lawful for an employer to dismiss someone on the grounds of their poor performance. However, the employment tribunal will expect an employer to follow a fair procedure, which would typically involve telling the employee what areas of their performance that need to improve, identifying ways to support the employee (e.g. additional training, coaching), setting a reasonable period for improvement (which could be several weeks/months), and issuing a series of formal warnings before taking any decision to dismiss. 

Legal points

Prior to issuing a claim in the employment tribunal you need to contact the conciliation service ACAS to commence Early Conciliation (EC). ACAS is an independent body whose aim is to resolve employment disputes without the need to litigate the matter at the tribunal. There is no cost to you for engaging in EC and if it is successful it will bring and end to the matter and you will not have to issue proceedings.  If EC is unsuccessful you will be given a certificate number, which you will need to put on the tribunal claim form you submit to the tribunal. The actual deadline to commence a claim in the Tribunal will depend on when you start EC and the date the certificate is issued.

If you have been dismissed or are going through a performance management process at work you can call W?L on 01992 822828 to speak to our specialist employment solicitors to discuss your rights.

Why Which? Legal?

We're not on the clock. Our legal team will help you every step of the way, for a simple monthly fee.

0117 456 6132

Monday - Friday 8:30am - 6pm
Excluding Bank Holidays

Join Which Legal

*only £9/month plus a £29 joining fee. You can cancel anytime.

Useful links and documents

Case Studies

Useful Links